“The government cannot enforce its mountain of laws and regulations without voluntary compliance.” — Charles Murray
When the Process Safety Management (PSM) standard, 29 CFR 1910.119, first hit the books in 1992, it caused a lot of consternation among managers, especially safety managers, in the chemical process industries (CPI). While most agreed that the majority of the 14 elements of PSM would actually lead to improved safety, the requirement in paragraph (o) for compliance audits raised the most objections. Not that people objected to the idea of compliance audits, though. After all, this was a time when Peter Drucker’s popularity was at a peak; Peter Drucker, the management consultant to whom the phrase, “If you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it,” is often attributed.
No, what upset managers in the CPI was not the requirement of PSM to conduct compliance audits. It was the need to disclose those audits to OSHA inspectors upon request. “It’s as though your car is equipped with a device that reads the speed limit of the road you’re driving on and records your speed. Then, when you take your car in for safety inspection, it informs the state police of every time you were speeding.”
There is an element of that. OSHA’s instructions to personnel inspecting PSM-covered chemical facilities, CPL 03-00-021, directs OSHA inspectors to decide which units to inspect based in part on “Compliance audit records, including open and pending items.” The compliance audit serves as a roadmap to everything the facility already acknowledges that it is doing wrong.
What About Attorney-Client Privilege?
Early in the era of PSM, some facilities thought that they could get around sharing their compliance audits with OSHA by having their attorneys conduct the audit. “That way, we meet the requirement of the PSM standard, but the compliance audit is protected by attorney-client privilege.”
It doesn’t work.
If an audit is conducted to satisfy the mandatory regulatory requirement for compliance audits rather than strictly to provide confidential legal advice, OSHA does not consider the audit report to be protected by attorney-client privilege. The courts have consistently agreed with OSHA.
So, when an OSHA inspector shows up, whether as part of a programmed inspection or in response to an incident, facilities should expect them to demand to see the last two compliance audit reports. Last two? Yes, because the standard requires that “Employers shall retain the two (2) most recent compliance audit reports.” It doesn’t require retaining anything further back. To keep copies of older compliance audits is to invite problems, so don’t.
Certification
Regardless of who conducts the compliance audit—internal resources, third-party resources, or corporate attorneys—OSHA requires that employers certify the audit. Specifically, in 29 CFR 1910.119(o)(1), it says, “Employers shall certify that they have evaluated compliance with the provisions of this section at least every three years to verify that the procedures and practices developed under the standard are adequate and are being followed.”
There are two key words in this requirement: “employers” and “certify”.
The requirement is to “certify” the audit report. Not “verify”, “confirm”, “approve”, or “authorize”. “Certify.” Legally, a certification statement is a formal declaration of truth; a false certification is considered perjury and may be subject to criminal or civil penalties. It should be in the form, “I, [full name], certify that …” along with the signer’s name, signature, and date.
The regulation requires that the certification be by the employer. Not the third-party auditor or attorney (if one is used), but the employer. OSHA doesn’t say what level in the organization the signer needs to be, but it must be someone who could reasonably be authorized to make such a certification. So, probably not the maintenance technician who helped with the audit, and not necessarily the CEO, but the PSM coordinator could do it, or the safety manager, or even the plant manager.
The requirement for certification is not a soft requirement—failure to certify the compliance audit report could result in citations and fines. It is so easily done, however, that it would be silly to be fined for failure to certify a compliance audit after going to all the trouble to conduct it.
Compliance Audits in the RMP Rule
After OSHA issued the PSM standard, the EPA came out with the Risk Management Planning (RMP) rule, 40 CFR 68, which duplicated the OSHA PSM standard and expanded on it to better protect the community and environment. The RMP rule duplicates the OSHA PSM standard in Program 3 (although there has been some notable divergence between the two regulations in the last few years), and offers PSM-lite in Program 2.
The Program 3 Prevention Program is in Subpart D. Instead of 14 elements, it has 13 elements. The EPA does not recognize Trade Secrets as an element of process safety management, it treats Emergency Response has a separate subpart (Subpart E), and it has added a new element: §68.80 Third-party audits.
Program 3 has kept, however, §68.79 Compliance Audits. In the opening section, the EPA regulation states that “The owner or operator shall certify that they have evaluated compliance with the provisions of this subpart…” By “this subpart”, the regulation means Subpart D.
The required compliance audit is of the elements in Subpart D, not the entire regulation.
The Program 2 Prevention Program is in Subpart C. The EPA has reduced Program 2 to just nine elements, one of which is §68.58 Compliance Audits. The regulation mirrors the language in Program 3, requiring that “The owner or operator shall certify that they have evaluated compliance with the provisions of this subpart…” In this case, “this subpart” refers to Subpart C. Again, not the entire regulation.
A Roadmap to Improvement
The PSM standard is one of the most complicated OSHA regulations with which to comply. As a result, a periodic compliance audit is essential for keeping up with the requirements and discovering where renewed effort is needed. As uncomfortable as it is to know that a compliance audit report may serve as a roadmap for OSHA to a facility’s failings, it is also a roadmap to opportunities for improvement. It is much better to discover deficiencies yourself and fix them, than to wait for an inspector to discover those deficiencies and cite them.
Create a Record of Good Faith
Conduct compliance audits periodically. The regulations require audits at least once every three years and that the last two audits be retained. Remember that audit findings are to be celebrated—they reveal an opportunity to improve. Remember also that if an inspector finds a deficiency, not only will there be a citation and fine, but the deficiency will still need to be addressed, and now on OSHA’s schedule. So, use the compliance audits to find deficiencies, then address them promptly. That will create a record of good faith efforts to comply with one of the most complicated OSHA regulations on the books.